Every off-season brings roster turnover, this year is no different. The following Yankees should not be retained:
Jason Giambi: Giambi really belted out the final year of his 7-year $120M contract sporting a line of .247/.373/.502 in 145 games, which is the most he’s played since 2003. Even though durability wasn’t a problem this year, it is still a concern going forward, even more so with Giambi being 38 next year. With two time Gold Glove first basemen Mark Teixeira a free agent this year, Giambi’s poor fielding (-10 FRAA) must also be considered. Giambi had five really good seasons in his seven years in New York and I think we’ll all look back on the Giambi era in NY as a fun memory.
Bobby Abreu: The only Yankee to stay healthy and productive this year, Abreu played 151 or more games for the eleventh year in a row in 2008. What’s his secret to staying on the field? Well, you’d have to ask him. I’d say it’s his ability to stay away from balls near the wall and not risking injury. It shows in his fielding numbers as Bob was a -14 FRAA for the Yankees this year. Offensively, Abreu is simply in decline. I appreciate the type of player that he is. I love guys that really work the count, but the Bobby Abreu that has played for the Yankees is an aging one. He has posted only his career worst OBPs with us (.371 in ‘08, .369 in ‘07). Abreu will be 35 next year and is not the player he once was, he is no longer the answer in right field.
It’s time for the Yankees to get younger and better defensively.